A Program of CA

Supported by

Français
Back to Resources Print

The difference between needs and wants (BC)

Subject Area: Social Studies

Link to British Columbia Social Studies Curriculum:
  • A1 – apply critical thinking skills – including comparing, classifying, inferring, imagining, verifying, using analogies, identifying relationships, summarizing, and drawing conclusions – to a range of problems and issues
Links to the New Learning Standards :
  • Determine what factors led to particular decisions, actions, and events, and assess their short- and long-term consequences
  • Explain different perspectives on past or present people, places, issues, and events, and compare the values, worldviews, and beliefs of human cultures and societies in different times and places
Brief Overview of the Lesson:

The students will discuss the differences between needs and wants in the context of early fur trade between First Nations and Europe.

Estimated Time Required for Implementation:

One class period

Materials Needed:

Copies of the article “The Fur Trade in North America”

Suggested Implementation Strategy:
  • Begin the lesson by asking the students to identify items that have caused people or countries to explore or settle new areas in order to obtain them. Provide the students with examples to help them begin: 1) salt routes were established to bring salt to countries to use to preserve food; 2) England established trade routes to India to obtain spices.
  • Make a list of their suggestions and ensure that Aboriginal people traded furs for goods is included in the list.
  • Once this list has been completed, pair up the students and have them discuss and list ways in which the fur trade helped to settle Canada.
  • Allow a few minutes for the pairs to discuss the question and then have them report their ideas to the class.
  • Ask them if they know why the furs were in such demand and have them offer answers.
  • Give them a copy of the following article to read: The Fur trade in North America.
  • Ask them to outline how the fur trade both helped and hurt the relationship between the Europeans and the First Nations people.
  • Draw their attention to the fact that all of this development came about because of a fashion craze in Europe and the money that was to be made because of it.
  • Ask them to explain how attitudes towards the use of fur for clothing have changed and why they have changed.
  • Ask them to explain the difference between a NEED and a WANT. Needs are things that we truly can’t be without, such as nutritious food and a place to live Wants are things you’d like to have, but if you don’t have them, you’ll still survive and you’ll be just fine. Wants could be things like designer jeans, toys etc.
  • Ask the students to go back and examine the list of items they made at the beginning of the period and have them indicate which ones they think are needs and which ones are wants.
  • Have them explain why they think it is important for people to know the difference between needs and wants.
  • Explain to them that a financially responsible person knows the difference between needs and wants and therefore allocates their money to ensure their needs are met before their wants are purchased.
Evaluation:
  • Assess the discussion about needs and wants, and why they think it is financially important for people to know the difference.
Options for Consideration:
  • The students could debate whether or not the majority of exploration was done to meet needs or wants.
Possible Links to the Home Program:
  • Lesson 4 — Ages 11–13 “On the Web -—Needs and Wants”
Extended Learning Opportunities:
  • The students could outline the routes of exploration that occurred primarily because of the fur trade and describe how those furs were transported to Europe.

 

The Fur Trade in North America
Hat

The fur trade played an important role in the history of North America. For nearly 250 years, from the early 17th to the mid-19th century, the fur trade was a vast commercial enterprise across a wild, forested expanse.

Europeans, who wanted to be fashionable, didn’t know at the time that they were actually helping to develop our country.

The fashion that was so desired was the beaver hat. These hats became a fashion rage that spread all over Europe. European clothiers had used fur for many centuries to trim coats. European beavers were dying out because of over-hunting, and the new fashions, like hats, required a lot of beaver felt.

Also, on cold winter nights, in homes with no central heating, furs were used as blankets.

But where would they find the furs?

Traders traveled all over North America looking for beaver pelts to supply the demand in Europe. These fur traders traveled by water, as there were few roads at this time in North America. They mapped the rivers and lakes, which, in turn, helped future development.

The traders met the First Nations people, who were eager to do business with them. The fur traders were known as the “coureurs de bois” and were friends with the First Nations people.

When the waterways froze during the winter, which made travel impossible, the traders often stayed in the native villages until spring. Not only did they learn to speak native languages, they also learned how to survive in the wilderness.

They established an economic interdependence. The traders needed furs to sell to the European clothiers, and the native people wanted goods to make their lives easier.

The native people knew how to trap beavers. The traders had brought goods such as hatchets, pots, shoes, fabrics and glass beads to exchange for beaver pelts. The cost of these goods was measured in beaver pelts, for example, one pot = 5 beaver pelts, one hatchet = 10 beaver pelts. Often there was a long discussion, bartering over the price.

The fur trade determined the relatively peaceful patterns of Aboriginal-European relations in North America. A central social aspect of this economic enterprise was extensive intermarriage between traders and Aboriginal women, which gave rise to an indigenous fur-trade society that blended Aboriginal and European customs and attitudes. The fur trade filled a need and a want, for both groups.